I found this shoe to have some good points, and some not-so-good points.
First off, for those I've seen questioning the value of making a low-cut shoe water-proof, clearly they have never hiked a dew-covered meadow in the morning then spent the rest of the day with cold, wet feet. These shoes kept my feet dry on many such days. (As a mildly autistic person I value my alone-time and solo-hike a lot)
They are also light-weight, a big change over my usual hiking footwear, and they also only cost about a third of what I usually spend.
But:
Compared to my Keens, the toe-box on these shoes is fairly narrow and there was some notable pain as I adjusted to that.
The sole is soft, really soft, which is useful in slick-rock situations because it's grippy, but in broken-rock terrain I struggled. Not only did I feel all the sharp edges, but in those cases where I could only get part of my foot down on a surface these shoes left me feeling unstable. (And a solo-hiker does NOT want to fall!) Probably in part because my foot was contantly trying to fall off the side of the shoe, no matter how tightly I laced them, something I've never been bothered by with my Keens.
These shoes were delivered May 25 and the attached photo was taken June 25. Those orange spots are where I have worn through the top layer of the insoles after less than 200 miles (my Keens usually last a few thousand miles before I relegate them to the workshop and buy a new pair)
So:
Attractive price. Functionally waterproof. Light wieght. The sole is not terribly stable. The durability is questionable.
Though marketed as a hiking shoe I would clasify them as a casual walking shoes at best. For me they were an experiment in cost-savings but I have since put them on the shelf with other things headed to the resale-shop and purchased another set of pricy Keens.